The Spool List

Blog · Guides

How much does it cost to have a broken part remade? Modelling, material, fit

20 November 2026 · 3 min read ·

Short answer: remaking a broken or discontinued part costs modelling time (measuring the original and drawing it in CAD, usually the biggest share for a one-off), making it (3D printing, CNC or casting), the material, and any test fit and revision. A simple plastic clip with clear photos and measurements is a small job. A load-bearing gear or a part with threads and tight fits takes more modelling and may need CNC. Good photos and measurements are the cheapest way to cut the cost.

Post your broken part — free

Why is modelling usually the biggest cost?

To print or machine a part, someone needs a 3D model. If the manufacturer never published one, a maker has to measure the original, work out missing or broken sections, and draw it, often with a test print to check the fit. That's skilled design time. Once the model exists, more copies cost only the making.

What else affects the price?

Factor Why
Complexity Curves, clips, threads and gears take longer to model and check
Tolerances Parts that slide, snap or carry a bearing need test fits
Material Heat, load, sunlight or chemicals may rule out cheap plastics
Process 3D printing suits most plastic one-offs; CNC suits metal and precise fits
Test fit A first print to test, then the final, adds a round of work
Quantity A spare or two costs little extra once the model exists

For process trade-offs, see what custom 3D printing costs and what CNC machining costs.

What should I send?

  • The broken part's photos from every side, with a ruler or calliper in shot
  • Key measurements: hole diameters and spacing, thicknesses, overall size
  • Where it fits: photos of the mating parts or the space it sits in
  • What it does: load, heat, movement, outdoors, food contact
  • Make and model of the appliance or machine, and the part number if visible
  • Quantity, and whether you can post the original for measuring

If you have a 3D file already, check it with the STL Checker. For gears, the Spur Gear Generator helps you work out the module and tooth count to give the maker. For threads, use the Tap & Drill Size Chart.

Is it worth remaking a part rather than replacing the item?

Often, when the item is otherwise sound and the part is discontinued or only sold in an expensive assembly. It's also less waste. Safety-critical parts are different: anything carrying people, gas, high pressure or mains electricity should come from the manufacturer or a certified repairer.

On The Spool List spare parts market you post the part once for free, makers with verified printers and machines quote, and you choose. You pay the quote with no buyer fee, and the payment is protected until you confirm delivery.

Get quotes for your part

FAQ

Can a broken plastic part be 3D printed? Usually, yes. A maker models it from photos and measurements, or from the original if you post it, then prints it in a suitable material.

Why does the first copy cost more than the second? The first carries the modelling and test fit. Further copies only need printing or machining.

What if I can't measure the part accurately? Send clear photos with a ruler in shot, or post the original to the maker to measure.

Which parts shouldn't be remade this way? Safety-critical parts, such as those for gas, high pressure, mains electricity or anything carrying people, should come from the manufacturer or a certified repairer.

Got a part, a prop or a run that needs making?
Post it free and let makers bid. Your payment is protected until you confirm delivery.

Post a job I'm a maker

More from the blog